خلاصة:
Throughout intellectual history, the concept of “time” has always been regarded as one of the most fundamental ontological notions, inviting philosophical, religious, and scientific inquiry. Each intellectual tradition offers a unique narrative of time. If time is studied as a multidimensional phenomenon (not as an abstract concept), its traces become evident in Western philosophical thought, Islamic philosophical texts, and the laws of classical physics. This article employs a descriptive-analytical method to study the characteristics of the concept of time in Western philosophers’ (Plato, Aristotle), Islamic philosophers’ views (Ibn Bājja, Ibn Rushd), and Newtonian physics to elucidate their similarities and distinctions. A comparative analysis of the concept of time in these three frameworks—Western philosophy, Islamic wisdom, and Newtonian physics—reveals both shared and divergent dimensions, yielding a deeper understanding of time’s complex nature. Thus, this paper seeks to address the following question: How have philosophical definitions of time and the derived concepts paved the way for Newton to describe time based on mathematical choices? The findings of this research lead to a comparative framework that juxtaposes the aforementioned philosophers’ views with Newton’s and demonstrates their direct and indirect influences on Newtonian physics.
ملخص الجهاز:
Philosophy of Science, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies Scientific Semiannual Journal (Research Article), Vol. 14, No. 2, Autumn and Winter 2024 From Metaphysics to Mechanics: A Comparative Reading of the Concept of Time In Western, Islamic, and Newtonian Physics Philosophical Perspectives Faezeh Eskandary * Razieh Borjian ** Abstract The concept of "time" has always been subject to philosophical, religious, and scientific reflection throughout the history of thought as one of the most fundamental ontological concepts.
In this article, an attempt has been made to discuss some characteristics of time, including continuity or connection, divisibility, the non-composition of these concepts from indivisible parts, and the infinity of time from the perspective of Plato and Aristotle as early Western philosophers, and Ibn Bajja and Ibn Rushd as Muslim philosophers in the Islamic West, and to provide arguments in favor of them as much as possible.
It is necessary to mention that so far, no research has been conducted that independently addresses this subject; however, in scientific works and sources, the concept of time has been studied in a scattered and limited manner from the perspective of philosophers such as Plato (pleshkov, 2020) (pleshkov, 2019), Aristotle (coope, 2006) (seissl, 2024), and Newton (Gorham, 2011) (Fanchi, 2023) as a physicist.
To this end, in this article, after examining the evolutionary course of the concept and characteristics of time from the perspectives of Plato, Aristotle, Ibn Bajja, and Ibn Rushd, it will be shown how Newton established the framework of new physics by synthesizing the duality of real/mental time and the mathematical analysis of motion.