Аннотация:
One of the most important financial rules is the inheritance of people from one another if the condition exists, which has always been prevalent across the nations and followers of holy religions. In this regard, Islamic Sharīʿa has provided precise legislations that determine the ranks and levels of heirs and their shares. According to most inheritance āyahs, all eligible individuals, regardless of their religious relations will inherit from one another. These general rules, supported unanimously by Farīqayn juriconsults are established with conclusive evidence; including reports indicating that non-believers will not inherit from Muslims. However, Islamic sects disagree whether Muslims inherit from non-believers or not. The majority of common juriconsults (Fuqahā-yi ʿĀmmih) believe that Muslims don’t inherit from non-believers. On the other hand, Imāmīya juriconsults and a few of the common juriconsults assert that Muslims do inherit from non-believers. The key point is that Imāmīya juriconsults unanimously believe that in case of the existences of a Muslim heir, the non-believing heir will be deprived of inheriting from a non-believer, even if the Muslim belongs to a more distant rank and the non-believer is closer in rank. The present research investigates the issue of the Muslim’s disinheritance from a non-believing heir, using the descriptive-analytical method and document analysis. Contrary to popular belief, the study concludes that arguments in favor of disinheritance are incomplete and the non-believing heir will inherit from the non-believer according to the general rules of inheritance.
Автоматическая аннотация:
For example, one can refer to the following books: Sheikh Mufid in "Al-I'lam bima Ittafaqat 'alayhi al-Imamiyya min al-Ahkam", Sayyid Murtada in "Al-Intisar" and "Nasiriyat", Sheikh Tusi in "Al-Mabsut", "Al-Khilaf", and "Al-Nihaya", Abu al-Salah al-Halabi in "Al-Kafi", Ibn Zuhra in "Ghunya", Ibn Hamza in "Al-Wasila", Ibn Idris in 'Al-Sara'ir', Muhaqqiq in 'Shara'i' and 'Mukhtasar al-Nafi', Allamah in 'Qawa'id al-Ahkam' and 'Irshad al-Adhhan', Shahid in 'Durus', Shahid al-Thani in 'Masalik', Muhaqqiq Ardabili in 'Majma' al-Fa'ida', Sabzawari in 'Kifayat al-Fiqh', Fadil Hindi in 'Kashf al-Litham', Tabataba'i in 'Riyad', Naraqi in 'al-Mustanad', Sahib Jawahir in 'Jawahir al-Kalam', Khoei in 'Muhadarat fi al-Mawarith', Imam Khomeini in 'Tahrir al-Wasila', Subhani in 'Nizam al-Irth fi al-Shari'a al-Islamiyya al-Gharra', Ruhani in 'Fiqh al-Sadiq' and others.
Al-Shahid al-Thani, after quoting this opinion from the researcher, says: This is a ruling that is famous among the companions; rather, it seems there is no disagreement regarding it, while from the reports, no explicit evidence for it exists other than the narration of Hasan ibn Salih.
Kulayni, al-Kafi, 7/143, Chapter on the Inheritance of the People of Different Religions, Hadith 1; Ibn Babawayh, Kitab man la yahduruhu al-Faqih, 4/244, Hadith 783; Tusi, Tahdhib al-Ahkam, 9/366; Tusi, al-Istibsar, 4/190; Hurr al-Amili, Wasail al-Shi'a, 17/374.
Considering the opinions of the masters of Rijal regarding Hasan ibn Salih, the narrator of the hadith, and his description of weakness, corruption of creed, and narration, how can this hadith be relied upon and, based on it, a fatwa be given regarding the exclusion of a Muslim from a non-believing heir?!