Аннотация:
Muslim philosophers initially define 'knowledge' as the 'presence of the known to the knower' and, on this basis, divide knowledge into two types: acquisitive (husuli) and presential (huduri). Since they consider this division to be a rational necessity, they generalize it to the knowledge of God as well. Consequently, they have raised the question: is divine knowledge acquisitive or presential? The Peripatetics and a few others among ancient and modern philosophers, although they consider God's knowledge of Himself to be presential, regard His knowledge of creatures as acquisitive. However, Suhrawardi, Sadr al-Muta'allihin, and almost all their followers until now have considered God's knowledge of Himself and of everything other than Him (ma'sawa) to be presential. Since from the time of Suhrawardi to the present, the view that God's knowledge is acquisitive has very few supporters and almost everyone has considered divine knowledge to be presential, this article is dedicated to the critique and examination of the theory of the presential nature of God's knowledge. The author, based on rational and traditional evidence, attempts to prove that this theory, despite its fame, prevalence, and popularity—especially from the time of Mulla Sadra until now—is an incorrect theory regarding divine knowledge and contradicts the judgment of reason as well as verses and hadiths.
Автоматическая аннотация:
Critique of the Theory of the Presence-based Nature of God's Knowledge from the Perspective of Reason and Tradition Dr. Ali Afzali 1 Abstract Muslim philosophers initially define "knowledge" as the "presence of the known with the knower," and based on this, they divide knowledge into two types: acquisitive (husuli) and presentational (huduri).
1 العلم عبارة عن حضور شيء عند شيء فما لا حضور عنده لشيء لا علم له بذلك الشيء 2 In philosophy, within the discussions of knowledge, this meaning has been realized, namely that knowledge consists of the presence of something for another thing 3 .
C_ God is aware of all possibilities through presentational knowledge of His own Essence; This is a response that some philosophers, including the Peripatetic philosophers, and sometimes Mulla Sadra, usually give to the aforementioned objections, because since God's knowledge cannot be considered presentational based on the definition of 'the presence of the known to the knower' and for the reasons mentioned, philosophers have tried to find another way to escape the aforementioned objections.
However, the late Allameh Tabataba'i also, following Sadr al-Muta'allihin and based on this same theory that "in addition to the knower, the known must also be incorporeal," considers knowledge of material things to be impossible: In philosophy, in the discussions of knowledge, this meaning has been realized that first, knowledge consists of the presence of something for another thing, and second, knowledge is equivalent to incorporeal existence...