Аннотация:
The article 'God's Knowledge of Things Before Creation; The Superiority of the Science of the Unknown Viewpoint over the Theory of Global Knowledge while maintaining Detailed Discovery' (Moin al-Din and Nassiri, 1393: No. 165/23-188) faces problems from various sides in proving the superiority of the 'Science of the Unknown' paradigm in explaining the quality of pre-creation knowledge. The path taken by the article, contrary to the claim of proving superiority and stating advantages, is directed towards invalidating the rival view and proving the selected view. This trajectory is drawn around these points: a transformational explanation of the rival theory and reducing it in some principles and dimensions, criticisms of the rival theory based on an incomplete and unacceptable formulation of it, denying the relational essence (dhat al-idafa) from the concept of knowledge, rejecting intuitive knowledge (ilm al-huduri), and proposing theories unrelated to the subject of the article; and most astonishingly, attributing their own view to narrations (hadiths) through direct interpretation of the title and content of the narrations and erroring the opposing view, and titling the selected view with the invented term 'Science of the Unknown' without a genealogy of its creators. Despite the orientation of the article's title to show the superiority of the selected view, the invalidation of the rival view results in denying the claim of the relational essence from the concept of knowledge and the reckless attribution of their own view to the pure realm of the Ahl al-Maqsur. A critical examination of this article and a methodological measure of its claims, consistent with precise criteria, can be a way to guard the heritage of the theistic sages and avoid literalism in the structure of theology.
Автоматическая аннотация:
This trajectory is drawn around these points: a transformationalist explanation of the rival theory and reducing it in some foundations and dimensions, criticisms of the rival theory based on an incomplete and unacceptable formulation of it, the negation of the relational status (dhat al-idafah) from the concept of knowledge, the rejection of presence-based knowledge (ilm al-huduri), and the presentation of theories unrelated to the subject of the article; and most astonishingly, attributing their own view to the traditions (hadiths) to the extent of direct interpretation of the title and content from the traditions, declaring the opposing view erroneous, and titling the selected view with an invented title.
These claims begin with accusing Sadra in theology of anthropomorphic theology, originating from the belief in the affinity between the Necessary and the contingent, and continue with the accusation of Sadra fabricating relational status for the concept of knowledge, the inadequacy of Sadra's theory in explaining God's knowledge of non-existents and impossibilities, the unexplainability of the quality of the attachment of divine knowledge to details before their detailed creation, equating Sadra's theory with the theory of the unity of the knower and the known in God, the groundlessness of presence-based knowledge, and the claim that the Exalted Truth is the "All-in-All," until it leads to the pre-determined conclusion, which is the negation of all foundations of Transcendent Wisdom.