چکیده:
Epistemology, as an independent discussion, was not presented in the books of previous philosophers and only after Kant's philosophy did this discussion emerge as an independent field. In some cases - such as Kant's own philosophy - it was presented as the only possible philosophical discussion. In Islamic philosophy, although there is no independent chapter under this title, the principles of epistemological discussions have been raised within other philosophical discussions. One of the main discussions in Islamic philosophy that has a close relationship with major epistemological issues is the discussion of mental existence. The present article begins by presenting an analytical proof from Islamic philosophers regarding the realism of knowledge, and then discusses three well-known theories among Islamic scholars and theologians. These three theories are: (1- The theory of addition 2- The theory of phantoms 3- The theory of mental existence. After explaining each of these theories, it mentions the theory of mental existence as the theory believed by the majority of Islamic philosophers, and finally explains the argument of Islamic philosophers known as real propositions, according to which, if we do not accept the theory of mental existence and complete correspondence between the mind and the external world, we will inevitably lose real propositions, which are fundamental propositions that constitute all theoretical sciences.
خلاصه ماشینی:
2)… Then the author and commentator proceed to reject the philosophers’ theory about the obtaining of the form of a thing in the mind, and He proceeds to reject the arguments of the philosophers by referring to the words of Fakhr al-Razi in “Mabahith al-Mashriqiyyah” and also his other book called “Al-Mulakhkhas,” and he quotes a detailed passage from Al-Mulakhkhas in which Fakhr al-Razi, while rejecting the philosophers’ theory, says: “We said this is an admission that knowledge is not the obtaining itself.
At the end of the discussion of the essence of knowledge, while expressing the theory of relation on behalf of the majority of theologians, he tried to remove the objections raised against it, and regarding the objection to knowledge of external non-existents, he says, ‘As for the objection to it in the knowledge of external non-existents, it is removed either by choosing mental existence, as Imam al-Razi went to in Mabaḥith al-Mashriqiyyah, and claimed that knowledge is a specific relation, not a rational form, for what you have known from the story of the inanimate object, or by the relation being dependent on the distinction that does not depend on the existence of the distinguished things, neither in the external world nor in the mind.
And since the obtaining of these forms is impossible in the external world, their forms must be in be in the mind – therefore, Razi, alongside his theory about the essence of knowledge, which is the same as connection and relation, also believes in the existence of imprinted forms, and the commentator of Mawaqif solved this problem through distinction, which apparently means rational consideration.