چکیده:
This article seeks to provide a sustained treatment of the complex role that equality plays in procedural thought. In this situation we are faced with two mentalities about procedural equality in the judicial process. Firstly, procedural equality is an inevitable necessity, and secondly, how this ideal concept should be considered in the design and evaluation of all types of judicial systems. However, due to the lack of a precise definition, we are not completely sure what exactly is meant when the concept of equality is expanded under the rules of procedure, and in fact, we are confused due to the consequences caused by the apparent branches of procedural law. In short, we know that we cannot have a fair trial without procedural equality, but we are not sure what it means exactly? This double rhythm has shaped the discussions of procedural equality in academic literature and judicial procedure. This article aims to examine the obvious and complex role played by equality in criminal and civil proceedings.
خلاصه ماشینی:
" 4 However, there is a distinction between equality in the philosophical sense used in constitutional law texts based on the psychological perception of society regarding the concept of equality, and procedural equality in the sense used in procedural law; with the clarification that psychologically, the general public's perception of the outcome of a proceeding, regardless of the structure in which it is conducted and without being directed toward specific legal articles, is based on substantive justice; such that a rendered verdict is considered just if, without considering the reliance of the verdict on specific laws and the rules and formalities cited to reach the stage of finality 1 649Asgari, Ali Asghar.
5 Consequently, it can be said that the concept of procedural equality, within the framework of an adversarial judicial system—whether it flows through civil proceedings or appears in the form of an accusatory system in criminal proceedings—strives to ensure that accurate and acceptable judicial results are achieved by creating a relative level of performance by the parties to the lawsuit, including both beneficiaries and non-beneficiaries, regarding the facilities and information required for the proceeding, in shaping the facts and events of the case.
of Legal 650 Journal of Legal Research, Vol. 24, No. 61, Spring 2025 2-1- Equality in Means from the Perspective of Civil Procedure 6 Based on the primary rule, the burden of proof lies with the plaintiff; however, an expansive interpretation of this obligation, meaning imposing ً certain evidentiary requirements on a plaintiff for which public access to such information is generally unavailable, means imposing an impossible obligation.