چکیده:
The superiority of mystical discovery over philosophical reason, in terms of the presence-based nature of revelatory sciences and the necessity of measuring and substantiating mystical discovery with reason, is a remote problem in epistemology for which a solution must be found. Reason is a problematic matter, and discovery, in various stages of spiritual journeying, does not possess equal cognitive ranks; therefore, the relationship between the various ranks of reason and the different ranks of discovery must be considered in the judgment between reason and discovery. This article first examines the views of logicians, philosophers, and mystics regarding the meanings of reason and the ranks of discovery, then by examining the strengths and weaknesses of reason against discovery, determines why some revelations are averse to reason? And what kind of reason can be a judge regarding what kind of discovery? Finally, specific points regarding the position of reason in judging discovery are stated.
خلاصه ماشینی:
). Some consider the solution to the problem, in a general sense, by referring both reason and revelation to infallible discovery and, in other words, to the Sharia and definitive religious texts, or by referring to 'nafs al-amr' (the matter itself), which is discovered through presence knowledge (16, p.
Certainly, someone who has more firm steps in mysticism can judge the discovery of someone who is at a lower level, and the fact that the opinion of the infallible ones and the Sharia is the decisive word in this matter falls under this same category; however, referring discovery to infallible revelation and religious texts does not completely solve the problem either, because the understanding and interpretation of texts returns once again to reason or discovery, which in this way makes this solution necessitate circularity.
In fact, on one hand, philosophical rules, which are the product of thinkers' thoughts and human mental activity, are not consistent in many cases, but rather uncoordinated and even contradictory; and on the other hand, because the subject of revelation in many instances concerns the states of realms beyond matter, it is outside the limits of reason and our conventional experiences; meaning it is beyond-rational and beyond the nature of reason.
The denial that gnostics have toward the intellect of philosophers is of this same nature; meaning, from their perspective, even the intellect of philosophers is excluded from reaching the lofty realms of discovery, and the reason for this is what was previously mentioned: that the formation of the human intellect begins with sensation, its leaven is the laws governing the material world, and ultimately, assuming correct movement, it obtains a set of intellectual concepts that, at most, provide a general schema of the realities of existence.