چکیده:
The discussion of the relationship between religion and ethics is considered one of the most important topics in the philosophy of religion. Regarding the types of connection between religion and ethics, two perspectives can be discussed: 1. The historical and scientific perspective 2. The logical and theoretical perspective. The historical and scientific perspective means examining what connections and relationships the two phenomena of religion and ethics have had with each other in practice and reality throughout human history, and across all historical religions. In this article, this historical examination is not the objective. However, the logical and theoretical perspective aims to determine what theoretical and logical possibilities exist for the connection and relationship between these two phenomena, regardless of whether each of these possibilities exists or not, and then their logical and theoretical strengths and weaknesses are examined. Our goal in this article will be this logical and theoretical examination.
خلاصه ماشینی:
Criticism and Review Based on two fundamental reasons, this view cannot be considered an independent theory regarding the relationship between religion and ethics: 3.
First reason: Upon careful examination of this theory, it becomes clear that what its proponents intend is not that religion and ethics possess a unified identity, but rather that ethics is considered part of the permanent and unchangeable aspect of religion; in which case, the view of this group returns to the first theory.
Among the proponents of this view, there are three different types of perceptions that each lead to this theory: 1- The first perception says: Should it not be that religion should be sought among the religious, therefore, the answer to this question should also be asked of the religious: do you believe that religion and ethics are separate or not?
Those who say that by affirming "X is good, therefore God wants X," ethics becomes completely independent of religion, have only considered the first question and have neglected the second question.
That is, it can only be claimed that religion and ethics are independent of each other when there is not even a single case where it is necessary to refer to religious books to gain knowledge of its goodness or badness.
Third view: The non-independence of religion and ethics according to a weak narration: where in this case, the proponent must give answer A to the first question and answer A or B to the second question.