چکیده:
The nature of such sayings and the uncovering of the secrets hidden within them provides a new perspective on the historical and subsequently scientific encounter with this phenomenon. In almost all works written for or against Shathiyat, where rational denial or defense of Shathiyat is addressed and traces of proving or rejecting the logical justification of such sayings and expressions are seen, the intended meaning of reason is Aristotelian reason and the intended meaning of logic is Aristotelian bivalent logic. Although the source of errors and problems in Shathiyat lies in their inherently contradictory or seemingly contradictory nature rather than being non-contradictory, the logical solution to these problems lies not in Aristotelian logic but in a logic called fuzzy logic, which has also been implicitly and unconsciously referred to in the statements of the defenders of Shathiyat; however, the habit of historical adherence to Peripatetic rational laws and Aristotelian logical rules has not allowed even the most prominent researchers in this field, including Steys, the opportunity to break free from the narrow and dark framework of this logic.
خلاصه ماشینی:
Shatah, in the terminology of mystics, refers to the movement and agitation of the heart during the dominance of ecstasy, and the expression of that state in terms that, to the non-initiated, appear strange and difficult to comprehend; sometimes the outward appearance of these words may seem unpleasant or even contrary to etiquette and Sharia, while the inner essence of that speech is correct and upright, and the speaker has expressed it with a pure intention such that an outsider does not realize its true meaning.
Stace, although he refers to these shatahat as seemingly contradictory judgments, according to his own words, takes the doubt more strongly and proceeds to suggest that shatahat are explicitly logical contradictions; and of course, he adds that if we consider mystical shatahat merely as unconsidered contradictions we bring, this judgment does not refer to an indisputable and undeniable reality, but rather is mixed with expression and must be justified (Shaygan, 1373: 369).
Just as it can be inferred from the sayings of Otto, Suzuki, and Koestler, and the criticisms of Stace regarding them, the only way to understand the truth of shatahat is to accept the internal contradiction of the content of shatahat and to consider Aristotelian logic insufficient as a justification for them based on the accepted criteria of Peripatetic reason.
Consequently, according to Stace, if we once admit the shatahat-like or contradictory nature of the mystical experience, we are forced to submit to the theory expressed here regarding logic, meaning we must accept that logic does not apply to all experiences.