چکیده:
Some Christian philosophers, including Lynn Radder Baker, interpret life after death with a materialistic approach. Baker believes that her view of resurrection regarding personal identity has the greatest compatibility with the Christian afterlife. According to this view, the criterion for this personal identity is possessing first-person perspective characteristics; therefore, the person remains after death due to the survival of this characteristic and is resurrected again into a body suitable for that world, created by God's miracle. This article, after analyzing Baker's view on the relationship between resurrection and personal identity and her justification for the compatibility of her view with Christian doctrine, criticizes it. These include the existence of some internal inconsistencies as well as philosophical flaws such as reducing a human being to a single characteristic, and also the incompatibility of Baker's theory with certain religious doctrines. These flaws ultimately indicate Baker's failure to provide a materialistic interpretation of the Christian afterlife.
خلاصه ماشینی:
According to this view, the criterion for this personal identity is possessing the first-person perspective characteristic; therefore, the person remains after the death of the body due to the survival of this characteristic and is resurrected again into a body suitable for that world, which is created by the miracle of God. This article, after analyzing Baker's view on the relationship between resurrection and personal identity and her justification regarding the compatibility of her view with Christian doctrine, criticizes it.
2 To examine and analyze any new perspective, it is appropriate to first pay attention to the context in which the view is presented and other parallel approaches to that view; therefore, before proceeding to the introduction and analysis of Lynne Baker's view, as a materialistic Christian philosopher, other materialistic theories regarding life after death and human identity are briefly mentioned.
In short, in alignment with the Christian bodily resurrection, Baker believes that the first-person perspective, which is the main criterion of personal identity, guarantees the survival of the human person after the death of the worldly body by being constituted through a new eschatological body.
It is worth mentioning that Baker's view regarding life after death and the necessity of creating a body to preserve the first-person perspective is not limited to the resurrection and the Day of Judgment, but also includes the intermediate state (Barzakh); this is why, according to her view, the first-person perspective will immediately after the death of the body require a new body for its own survival.