چکیده:
The main question of this paper is: "What is the criterion in Ontological Argument (Burhane Siddiqin)?" This question can be analyzed into three questions as fallow: (1) what are the characteristics of this argument? (2) Which characteristics are to be considered as the criteria of it? (3) Which characteristics are to be considered as the advantages of it? This paper aims to answer these questions and comes to the conclusion that there are five characteristics for this argument: 1. The Necessary Being is to be proved by considering the existence. 2. The argument must produce the same result even if possible existents are denied. 3. The argument must be independent of the proof for the impossibility of the vicious circle and the infinity regress. 4. Real and actual attributes are to be used in this argument. 5. The argument is not influenced by the acceptance of possible existents or the rejection of them. Having read the paper، one will find that the first and the second characteristics are together the criteria of the mentioned argument، and the third is not relevant to it، while the forth and fifth ones are the advantages of it.
خلاصه ماشینی:
What is obtained by examining and scrutinizing the works of philosophers is that the Proof of the Sincere refers to a method of proving the existence of God in which the Necessary is proven through the observation of "pure existence" (16, p:62; 22, p:157) or, in other words, contemplation of "existence itself" or, in a third expression, the observation of the "nature of existence" (1, vol 3, p:66; 22, p:157).
In this phrase, Avicenna refers to two characteristics: one is the need of the Proof of the Sincere for contemplation of "existence itself" to prove the Necessary in itself—which was the first characteristic—and the other is its independence from the observation and consideration of the world of creation and action, or in philosophical terms, the world of contingency.
Now, with attention to these two premises, the formulation of Sadr al-Mutallahin's objection to Avicenna's proof will be as follows: There is no doubt that Avicenna, in his proof, through the observation of existence, seeks to prove the Necessary Being by Essence; likewise, we have no doubt that this proof does not depend on the acceptance of the world of possibility (13, vol.
In this formulation, Mulla Sadra has endeavored that, in addition to starting from the observation of the truth of existence in the path of proving the Necessary Being by Essence and having no need to consider the realm of possibility, the premises of the proof do not utilize conventional or metaphorical attributes at all and use only real and actual attributes.