چکیده:
Khafri, one of the renowned philosophers of the Shiraz philosophical school and the heir to both rival schools, Jalaliyah and Sadriyah, possesses two important treatises on the Liar Paradox. This puzzle, known among Muslim logicians as the 'Shubhat Jadh al-Asamm' (the problem of the deaf root), is one of the controversial topics in the Shiraz philosophical school. In his short monograph, 'Ibrat al-Fudala', Khafri proceeds to analyze and critique the views of his teacher of that era, and then, without a precise formulation of the puzzle, presents three solutions. He organizes his detailed treatise, titled 'Hayrat al-Fudala', according to the structure of 'Nihayat al-Kalam': an introduction presenting four formulations of the puzzle, the first goal in reporting and critiquing the views of predecessor scholars, and the second goal in presenting the author's five solutions. Although the two treatises were written at different times, Khafri wrote the second treatise to complement and refer to the first. In solving the puzzle of Jadh al-Asamm, Khafri has many extra-logical reflections: he considers the Jadh al-Asamm puzzle to be a paradox and presents various solutions in its resolution. Although the foundation of all Khafri's solutions in both treatises is based on selecting and resolving the conjunction or the elimination of contradictions based on 'the false whole of speech'—specifically the false part being the distinction of aspects, particularly the two types of truth and falsehood—the fragmentation of a philosopher's views in solving this puzzle is itself a noteworthy puzzle.
خلاصه ماشینی:
He organizes his detailed treatise titled "Hayrat al-Fudala" according to the structure of Dawani's "Nihayat al-Kalam": an introduction presenting four formulations of the puzzle, the first objective in reporting and critiquing the views of predecessor scholars, and the second objective in presenting the author's five solutions.
Although the foundation of all Khafri's solutions in both treatises is based on selecting the false part as "the entire statement is false" and the removal of conjunction or the lifting of contradictions based on the distinction of modalities (haythiyat), especially the two modes of truth and falsehood, the dispersion of a single philosopher's views in solving this puzzle is itself a puzzle worthy of contemplation.
The structure of the treatise Hayrat al-Fudala is organized in imitation of Nihayat al-Kalam (Dawani's detailed treatise on solving the Jadhra Asamm doubt): an introduction on the formulation of the puzzle, the first objective in reporting and critiquing the views of predecessors and the second objective in presenting the author's solutions.
He considers all of them reducible to five views, which are themselves based on two major foundations: "The last four views (namely the solutions of Dashtaki, Dawani, Ibn Kumuna, and Jurjani) are based on the premise that this doubt is neither true nor false; and the result of Taftazani's answer and the second answer of the author of Qistas is also based on the premise that the puzzle of 'كل كلامي كاذب' actually contains two propositions, and the truth of one necessitates the falsehood of the other, and vice versa.