چکیده:
The problems of the nature of motion and how it exists in the external world are among the most important philosophical discourses that have preoccupied the philosophers from the ancient Greece up to the Islamic era. The philosophers have brought up four theories in response to the question whether motion، while maintaining its unity، is a discontinuous or a continuous matter in the external world. Contrary to the philosophers before him، Mirdamad is the first Muslim philosopher who has openly talked about the external realization of motion in its both famous forms: mediating and intersect. Mulla Sadra although not as openly as his master، has defended this theory with a criticism of the proofs of those who deny intersect motion. In this paper we will compare the viewpoints of these two philosophers on this subject.
خلاصه ماشینی:
Mir Damad initially summarized Ibn Sina's objection regarding the non-existence of actual movement in the external world as follows: «إنّ المتحرّک ما لم یصل إلی المنتهی لم توجد الحرکهء بتمامها و إذا وصل،فقد بطلت الحرکهء», then following Khwaja Nasir al-Din al-Tusi (6, Vol: 2, pp: 43-53), by distinguishing between the past and future from the present, he responds to it in this way: movement either exists in the past or in the future, but the present itself is not counted as time; it is the end of the past and the beginning of the future.
Mulla Sadra, like Mir Damad, does not agree with the claim of the non-existence of actual movement in the external world, but he attempts, in addition to Ibn Sina's reasoning, to convey everything that might be said in justification of this view.
Response: Two responses have been given to this objection: First, Bahmanyar's response: He believes that this objection is only valid regarding actual movement, but the implication of accepting this statement is not that the mover's passage through the points existing in the path of movement was not a continuous and gradual passage, but rather that the mover enters each of the points suddenly and then exits it, so that the words of people like Fakhr al-Din al-Razi may be correct; because essentially, actual movement does not exist in the external world and is nothing more than a mental assumption.