چکیده:
Mulla Salih Mazandarani is a famous scholar of the eleventh century. Mulla Salih Mazandarani's commentary on Al-Kafi is one of the best commentaries of this book and has been written on its two sections, Usul and Rawdah. In this article, based on Mulla Salih's commentary on Al-Kafi, his method in explaining the hadiths is described, and then the methodological critique of Allamah Sha'rani regarding some of this commentator's views is presented. Mulla Salih Mazandarani's method in explaining the hadiths of Al-Kafi consists of: examining the chain of narration (sanad), explanation, and interpretation of the text. Also, his method in explaining the text consists of: etymology and semantics, citing Quranic verses, citing other narrations, and proving the content of the hadith.
خلاصه ماشینی:
Mulla Salih considers the purpose of mentioning this hadith in this chapter of Usul al-Kafi to be the explanation of the identity of the Divine attributes and essence.
He considered an essence devoid of existence and necessity to be existent and necessary, and also regarding His other attributes; either he did not understand the meaning of the identity of the attributes, or he did not make a distinction between universal concepts and their individuals.
The commentator explains the first assumption as follows: In the view of researchers, the meaning of the attributes is the very essence of the Divine.
1 Allameh Sha'rani writes in the footnote of this book regarding these phrases of the commentator: The phrase "His essence is instead of the attributes" is not the view of the researchers.
1 Allameh Sha'rani writes in criticism of this view: And what the commentator has mentioned in the interpretation of the hadith is not sufficient and does not align with the Imam's( words except with a specific assignment.
1 Allameh Sha'rani writes in criticism of Mulla Salih's commentary: The commentator's interpretation is contrary to the apparent meaning of the hadith; because considering the preceding and following context, the Imam's( statement is in the position of proving necessity in nature.
Semantics in the Commentary on the Hadith "The Soldiers of Intellect and Ignorance" To explain the semantics in Mulla Salih's commentary, the following examples are mentioned: A.