چکیده:
Among the important topics in the issue of resurrection is the eternity of disbelievers in Hell, given the infinite divine mercy; on one hand, the verses of the Quran and traditions explicitly state this, while on the other hand, rational arguments and mystical revelations present other ideas. In this article, after presenting the most important arguments of opponents and proponents, we will see that Sadr al-Mutallahin has directed his view toward a synthesis of opinions inspired by the Quran, demonstration, and mysticism by proposing the theory of the change in the essential nature of disbelievers. In the end, through a mystical revelation, he has leaned slightly towards the view of eternal punishment; however, it seems that both the path of reason and the path of mysticism in this field do not have the possibility of solving the problem, and the issue can only be resolved by adhering to the verses and traditions.
خلاصه ماشینی:
The Quranic verses have explicitly stated many times the eternal and lasting nature of the punishment of Hell for disbelievers and polytheists, their non-exit from it, and also its being painful, unpleasant, humiliating, and unmitigatable; therefore, "punishment" (azab) cannot under any circumstances be understood in the sense of sweetness and pleasantness, for in that case, the description "painful" (alim) would become meaningless.
(Hosseini Tehrani, 1423:386/10, 389 and 402) Therefore, in response to the first doubt, opponents say regarding the proportion of lifespan to the nature of the afterlife: eternity there does not mean temporal length; rather, it is within the duration of this world and in the essence of this realm, not in its breadth and extension; thus, the non-temporal stability of disbelief manifests in the hereafter in the form of eternity in Hell.
In response to the reason for the cessation of punishment and God's vast mercy (the fourth point), it can be said that after it has become clear that eternal punishment is inseparable from the effects and properties of the form of misery, and the species-like nature of the disbelievers has become the very essence of disbelief, the argument is answered by itself; because the intention of God's mercy is that God bestows upon a person in proportion to the perfect capacities acquired within them.
(1382:446) Thus, in the view of Sadr al-Muta'allihin, until before the book Al-Arshiyya, since his nature (or form or species-like disposition) has changed, the one whose punishment is permanent no longer feels suffering and pain and is eternal in hell; but he is not distressed or uncomfortable by his presence!