چکیده:
The present research, through an examination of the methodology of the theory of Ulama al-Abrar in the book 'The School in the Process of Evolution', has addressed a critique of it. First, by carefully examining the discussions of this book and the method of citation and reasoning that the author has employed to prove their view, an explanation of their research method is provided, and then the flaws in their method are examined. The author of this book suffers from some general flaws in their research method that are not specific to any particular science; including: failure to mention documentation in some important discussions, unmethodical analysis, fallacy in the use of sources, application of invalid criteria, and failure to distinguish between the beliefs of the Imams and some of the Shia commoners. Furthermore, flaws in the theological, hadith, historical, and rijalic methodology of this theory are evident. Therefore, the methodology of this theory has been examined based on the conventional methods in each of the aforementioned sciences, and its flaws have been explained. The result is that this theory is flawed in terms of research methodology and does not lead to a correct outcome.
خلاصه ماشینی:
The author of this book suffers from some general flaws in his research method that are not specific to a particular science; including: failure to mention evidence in some important discussions, unmethodical analysis, fallacy in the use of sources, application of invalid criteria, and lack of distinction between the beliefs of the Imams and some of the Shia commoners.
He expresses his reason for such an approach toward the sources as follows: If, for example, an author who is accused of ghulu (extremism) or a book that is spoken of as being subject to the potential interference of extremists, presents a hadith in support and reinforcement of the foundations of extremists, an aware and cautious researcher will involuntarily doubt the acceptance of that claim; even if the chains of transmission of that hadith are 'sahih a'la' (highest authenticity) from the author upwards or all its narrators are from the 'ashab al-ijma' (companions of consensus); but if that same author or source, attributes a statement refuting ghulu (extremism) to the Imam, the possibility that the extremist narrator has forged it or that an incompetent person—whose primary goal is to strengthen the foundations of extremists—has inserted or interpolated it into the text of the book, is noteworthy.
Of course, Modarresi refers to the words of Shahid al-Thani to confirm his interpretation of this narration, and quoting him in the book Haqaiq al-Iman, he says: Many of the companions of the pure Imams and the early Shiites considered them to be only righteous scholars and did not even believe in their infallibility.