چکیده:
Belief in an infallible successor in the Shia religion and the infallibility of the Pope in the Catholic religion are fundamental principles of faith in both religions; to such an extent that deniers of them are considered outside the religion. Contrary to this similarity, this subject differs between the two religions in terms of the nature of the subject, position, duties, conditions of the Imam, the role of the Imam/Pope, the proving evidences in the Book of Allah, Sunnah, and reason, the validity of the evidences, and also the method of their appointment. The present article aims to examine, critique, and then compare the two by explaining the structure of the subject and its supplementary aspects, in order to provide a basis for further dialogue for subsequent discussions and research.
خلاصه ماشینی:
Despite this commonality, this subject differs between the two religions in terms of the nature of the subject, status, duties, conditions of the Imam, the role of the Imam/Pope, the evidentiary proofs in the Book of God, Sunnah, and reason, the validity of the proofs, and also the method of their appointment.
» (Kulayni, 1385: 1/116) The Position of Imamate in the Shia School Imamiyyah theologians, based on the verses of the Quran and the Sunnah, consider the discussion of Imamate to be among the important theological and fundamental topics, and they believe that the Imam holds the status of Wilayah and the guidance of the Ummah from the side of God. They consider the necessity of the existence of an Imam to be obligatory, similar to the necessity of the existence of a Prophet, based on the rule of Lutf (Grace); regarding this necessity, they raise two subjects: the conditions of the Imam and his appointment.
The theological foundations of papal infallibility in Christianity consist of: the cessation of revelation in the post-apostolic period, the assistance of the Holy Spirit to the entire Church, and assistance to the Pope as the representative of Jesus and the visible head of the Church in matters of faith and moral commands.
In the Catholic school, the subject of the Pope, his infallibility, and his guidance was not only not institutionalized during the era of Jesus's mission, but it was also not explicitly raised in the Holy Bible later on.